So You’re a Conservative? Why Do You Hate Poor People?

“Every time we object to a thing being done by government, the socialists conclude that we object to its being done at all.”

– Frederic Bastiat

“There is an almost universal tendency, perhaps an inborn tendency, to suspect the good faith of a man who holds opinions that differ from our own opinions.” 

-Karl Popper

_____

Poisoning the well” isn’t something unique to political progressives. Lately, though, it seems to have become standard practice among Those On The Left to assume that anyone disagreeing with their policy positions is acting out of bad faith. Consider, for example, President Obama’s recent remarks on the Affordable Care Act:

“[Republicans have] spent the last few years so obsessed with denying [people] access to health insurance that they just shut down the government and threatened default over it.”

According to this narrative, opponents of Progressivism don’t simply have different ideas about how to make the world a better place. Opponents of Progressivism are actually just mean, spiteful people who want to harm others. Because they’re mean. Here’s another shining example from the College Democrats of America:

college dems

In other words, if you don’t support the Democrat Party’s specific plan for organizing the American healthcare system, you don’t care about human life. Because you’re trying to take away people’s healthcare. Meanie. Yet another example from left-leaning news site Slate:

“When we talk of cutting food stamps or gutting education, we shouldn’t just call it greed. We should call it a sin.”

Translation: “If I think the government should set aside X% of the federal budget for education, and you only think it should set aside Y% of the budget for education, YOU’RE A SINNER.”

When someone has the audacity to oppose re-defining society’s definition of marriage, the progressive is unable to comprehend that his opponent could be motivated by anything other than ill will toward homosexuals. Hence, the labels “bigot” and “homophobe” are swiftly handed down to anyone who disagrees with the progressive’s viewpoint.

When someone questions why businesses should be forced to offer their employees free birth control pills (but not free allergy pills, or free pain pills), the progressive indignantly asks why that person is “anti-women”.

buckley

Such rhetorical tactics are deeply authoritarian. “Agree with me, or you’re a bad person.” “Stay silent, or I’ll drag your name through the mud.”

It seems especially ironic, then, that this approach has been embraced by self-described crusaders of “tolerance” and “diversity”.

Advertisements

7 thoughts on “So You’re a Conservative? Why Do You Hate Poor People?

  1. Hey this is quite a fine reminder of what I’ve been saying. You used the word, sin. Liberals incessantly deny that there is any such a thing as sin(violation of God’s Will) until someone does, says, thinks anything that denies their will ( it’s an apotheosis of the leftist individual and of the state)

  2. I agree that this is a huge and fundamental problem. We can’t have a national conversation (about marriage, welfare, or whatever) if one side smears half the country as motivated by hatred rather than a sincere difference of opinion.

    I thought the (generally liberal) Onion’s take on this was funny and actually pretty insightful:
    “Conservative Acquaintance Annoyingly Not Racist”
    http://www.theonion.com/articles/conservative-acquaintance-annoyingly-not-racist,35236/

  3. If you want the full/nuanced argument (so you can represent the strongest version of your opponent’s argument), I recommend giving David Simon and Michelle Alexander a listen. I think they make a pretty strong case that intolerance/racism/etc are institutional and not overt as they once were. It makes sense to me to at least consider these arguments in making an appropriate assessment of the conservative vs progressive culture wars (which in my opinion is meaningless today).

  4. Yes, I have been an “evil conservative” for thinking there might be a better way to achieve a similar outcome (better health care for all, funding the government, etc.).

  5. An impressive share! I’ve just forwarded this onto a colleague who was doing a little research on this.
    And he actually bought me lunch simply because I found it
    for him… lol. So let me reword this…. Thanks for the meal!!
    But yeah, thanx for spending the time to talk about this subject here on your web
    page.

Comments are closed.